top of page
Shark 13 Colour.png

This Restaurant Lost Me Before I Even Walked In - Pricing Psychology matters

Writer: Jay Leshark
Jay Leshark
Aug 10
4 min read

Why Confusing Pricing Is One of the Biggest Marketing Mistakes a Business Can Make


I recently came across a brand-new restaurant in Phuket.


Excited to check it out, I did what most people do in 2026 before deciding where to eat:

I went online and looked at the menu.

Now, this restaurant specialises in steak, and visually the place looked fantastic. Nice branding. Nice atmosphere. Great photography. The kind of venue that should have instantly made me want to book a table.


Instead, within about 30 seconds… I decided I would never go there.

Not because of bad reviews.Not because of the food.Not because of the service.

I’ve never even stepped foot inside the restaurant.

The reason?

The pricing completely frustrated me.

Every steak on the menu was priced per gram.

Some cuts were one price per gram.Others were higher depending on whether it was grass-fed, wagyu, imported, marble score, and so on.


And instantly my brain went from:

“Wow, this looks good…”

to:

“How much is this actually going to cost me?”

And that is where the restaurant lost me.


Marketing Isn’t Just About Attraction — It’s About Removing Friction

This is something businesses constantly forget.

Good marketing doesn’t just create desire.

Good marketing removes uncertainty.

The moment a customer becomes confused, frustrated, overwhelmed, or mentally exhausted, you create friction.

And friction kills sales.

In this case, I suddenly had a hundred questions:

  • How heavy are the steaks?

  • Is the weight before cooking or after?

  • What’s the average size?

  • Am I accidentally ordering a 4,000-baht steak?

  • Why do I need to calculate dinner like I’m doing maths homework?

  • Why can’t you just tell me the final price?


Now maybe there’s a perfectly logical reason the restaurant does it this way.


But here’s the brutal truth about marketing:

If the customer has to work too hard to understand your offer, many simply leave.

And that’s exactly what I did.


The Customer Experience Starts LONG Before the Customer Arrives

This is the part businesses underestimate.

The experience didn’t start when I walked through the restaurant doors.

The experience started online.

It started the second I opened the menu.

And my experience was confusion.

That confusion then became frustration.

And frustration became rejection.

What’s fascinating is that this restaurant has now created negative word-of-mouth from someone who has never even eaten there.

That’s how powerful first impressions are in marketing.


Businesses Often Accidentally Make Customers Feel Stupid

One of the biggest hidden mistakes in marketing is making customers feel uncertain or unintelligent.

Customers don’t want to feel confused.

They don’t want to calculate.They don’t want to decode pricing systems.They don’t want ambiguity.

They want clarity.

This is why companies like Apple became masters of marketing.

Simple pricing.Simple choices.Simple communication.

The easier something is to understand, the safer it feels to buy.

And safety matters massively in consumer psychology.

Especially in hospitality.

Because nobody wants to sit in a restaurant stressed about what the bill might become.


Complexity Creates Anxiety

There’s a huge psychological principle at play here:

Confused customers rarely become confident buyers.


When people cannot predict the outcome of a purchase, anxiety increases.

That anxiety causes hesitation.

Hesitation kills conversions.

This applies to far more than restaurants.

It happens with:

  • Hotels hiding extra charges

  • Tour companies with confusing packages

  • Gyms with complicated memberships

  • Agencies with unclear pricing

  • Websites overloaded with options

  • Restaurants with menus that feel like spreadsheets


Businesses think complexity makes them look premium.

Often, it just makes customers leave.


“But High-End Steak Restaurants Do This…”


Yes, some do.

And sometimes it works.


But there’s a major difference:

The best premium restaurants still guide the customer clearly.


They might price by weight, but they also:

  • Explain typical sizes

  • Show estimated total prices

  • Give recommended cuts

  • Help customers understand what they’re ordering

  • Remove uncertainty from the experience


That’s the key difference.

Luxury should feel effortless.

Not confusing.


The Dangerous Part? Most Businesses Never Know Why They Lost the Customer

This is what fascinates me most.

That restaurant will probably never know they lost a potential customer because of menu psychology.

They’ll never see:

  • The people who closed the menu

  • The customers who got overwhelmed

  • The guests who decided somewhere else felt “easier”

  • The negative opinions formed before arrival


Businesses usually only measure the people who buy.

But the real marketing lesson is understanding why people didn’t buy.

And sometimes the smallest frustrations create the biggest losses. Thats why Pricing Psychology matters.


Marketing Is About Reducing Mental Effort

One of the most underrated business skills is simplicity.

The easier you make decisions:

  • The more customers trust you

  • The more relaxed customers feel

  • The more likely they are to purchase

  • The better the customer experience becomes


Great marketing reduces thinking.

Bad marketing increases it.

And in a world where consumers are overwhelmed with choices already, the businesses that win are often the ones that make decisions feel easiest.


Pricing Psychology

What’s interesting is this restaurant may genuinely serve incredible steaks.

But I’ll probably never know.

Because they lost me before the experience even began.

And that is one of the biggest lessons in modern marketing:

Sometimes customers don’t leave because the product is bad.


They leave because the process felt frustrating.

And in business, frustration spreads far faster than quality ever does.


Pricing Psychology a confusing menu

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page